The Rise of Market Participation and the Risks of Alternative Assets

Over the past five years, the Indian stock market has experienced significant growth, underscoring a broader shift among investors toward financial assets over traditional savings instruments. This transition toward channelling savings into investments—rather than low-yield, conventional options—marks a progressive trend, particularly in light of persistent inflationary pressures eroding the purchasing power of money or value of money.

According to Trading Economics, India’s average annual inflation rate over the last five years stood at approximately 5.8%, compelling investors to seek avenues that outpace rising prices. While the equity market remains a primary focus, the search for inflation-beating returns has also spurred interest in alternative investment avenues. However, these alternatives often entail heightened risks due to their inherent volatility, limited regulatory oversight, and inadequate disclosure practices by fund managers, exposing investors to elevated potential losses. This evolving landscape highlights the growing need for balanced strategies that harmonize growth opportunities with prudent financial planning.

Several factors have contributed to this surge in investment, including increased financial awareness, the rise of online trading platforms, and improved money management knowledge. This trend gained significant momentum after the COVID-19 pandemic. During 2020, the market experienced a sharp downturn but demonstrated a strong V-shaped recovery by mid-to-late 2021. Many investors capitalized on this rebound, earning substantial profits, which further fuelled interest in the stock market and encouraged more individuals to enhance their market knowledge and participation.

alternative-assets-marketexpress-in

The continuous rise in market participation is a positive sign, indicating further potential for both the stock market and the broader economy. However, this trend also raises certain concerns for the economy and investors behaviour alike and also more prone to the short-term fluctuations of the market.

One key issue is the shift of funds from savings to investments. According to recent data from the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, Indian household savings have significantly declined over the past five years, with net financial savings reaching a five-year low in 2022-23, indicating a trend where people are investing more of their income than saving it, with this investment often directed towards financial market. As more money moves from traditional savings accounts to Demat accounts, banks may experience a reduction in cash reserves. This could lead to liquidity constraints, especially if the demand for loans increases. In such a scenario, banks might have to rely on additional money printing, which could further fuel inflation.

Moreover, while investors have access to various resources that teach investment strategies, fundamental and technical analysis, very few emphasize the importance of investors’ behaviour and psychology—particularly when to exit the market. This is crucial, as most Indian investors tend to be loss-averse. In times of market downturns, panic- selling due to herd-mentality often results in unnecessary losses. A strong mindset, proper diversification, and a long-term holding strategy are essential for sustained success in the stock market. Emotional discipline helps investors navigate market volatility without making impulsive decisions.

Since October 2024, India’s major indices, Nifty 50 and Bank Nifty, have been on a continuous decline, significantly eroding investor wealth. Nifty has fallen nearly 15% from its September peak, wiping out approximately ₹85 trillion (nearly $1 trillion) in market value. Due to their inherent loss aversion, many investors are now exploring alternative investment avenues beyond traditional stocks.

This shift has led to growing interest in emerging asset classes such as Bitcoin, meme coins, stablecoins, NFTs, and digital art. These alternative investments have gained traction primarily because of their low correlation with the stock market, making them attractive during periods of equity market downturns.

However, these investments carry significantly higher risks. Unlike traditional assets, they lack fundamental backing or tangible intrinsic value and are driven purely by demand dynamics, making it difficult to predict what influences their demand and when. While stock prices are also influenced by demand, they are supported by underlying business fundamentals, making them comparatively less volatile and less risky. Additionally, the absence of supply controls and limited regulatory oversight further contribute to extreme price fluctuations, increasing the risk associated with these alternative investments.

Bitcoin, the largest cryptocurrency, has declined by 21% from its January 20 peak, returning to levels last seen after Donald Trump’s U.S. presidential election victory in November. This drop comes as hopes for a strategic Bitcoin reserve fade. Other cryptocurrencies have suffered even steeper losses, with Ether plunging over 40% since December.

A new trend has emerged in the alternative investment space, where newly launched coins are attracting significant investor interest, much like IPOs in the stock market. However, unlike IPOs, these coins often lack fundamental backing, making them inherently riskier.

Trump’s own meme coin, which he launched just days before his inauguration—raising concerns over potential conflicts of interest—has also plummeted, losing 80% of its value from its January peak, according to CoinMarketCap data

Analysing the long-term sustainability of these coins is challenging, as they lack fundamental backing, making traditional fundamental analysis nearly impossible. These assets are driven purely by speculation and luck, often delivering exponential returns in a short period, only to experience significant declines just as quickly.

However, investing is a science that requires discipline, strategy, Analysis and a long-term perspective. To build sustainable wealth, investors should remain committed to long-term investments rather than chasing short-term, high-risk opportunities. Along with strong fundamental investment strategies, a well-diversified portfolio and a resilient mindset are crucial for navigating market uncertainties and achieving financial success.